Sample with mock data

Your Agency Scorecard

Prepared for a subscription brand (sample), December 2026

Day 1: What you send

PDF
Monthly PDF report
Paid social agency
EMAIL
Email update
Creator program
DOC
Word doc recap
Influencer agency
CSV
CSV export of campaign results
Search agency
CSV
Billing and subscription export
Your billing

Whatever you already get works: PDFs, emails, docs or CSV exports from your agencies and ad accounts. About 30 minutes of your time.

No logins or system access. Exports only, deleted after your readout.

Day 5: What we find

1,680
customers claimed by partners
1,060
found in your billing
718
still subscribed at 90 days

"Still subscribed at 90 days" means the customer was still an active subscriber 90 days after they signed up, according to your own billing records, not the partner's report.

Paid social agency
ROAS 4.2x, 720 conversions
420 customers, 250 still subscribed at 90 days
Search agency (clean CSV)
350 conversions
330 customers, 260 still subscribed at 90 days
Creator program
Engagement up 38%, 230 sign-ups
120 customers, 65 still subscribed at 90 days
Affiliate partner
170 referrals
150 customers, 125 still subscribed at 90 days
Influencer agency
1.2M impressions, 210 conversions
40 customers, 18 still subscribed at 90 days

The partner with clean data was close. The ones grading themselves in PDFs were off by up to 5x.

Day 10: Your scorecard

$90K spent Jun to Aug ($30K a month). $125 per customer who stayed.

"Cost per customer who stayed" is what you paid a partner, divided by the customers it brought in who were still subscribed 90 days later. Lower is better.

Tap a partner to see why it got its verdict.

Spend we couldn't trace: $13K (14%)

  • Creator program, $5KNo unique codes.Fix: A promo code per creator.
  • Paid social, $8KTop-of-funnel campaigns without tracked links.Fix: Tracked links on every campaign.
  • Paid socialMonthly PDF only.Fix: Ask for the raw CSV export, not just the summary.

Day 14: Your readout

3 moves for January: about 400 more customers who stay, and $15K a year back

  1. 1Cut the influencer agency and move its $3K a month to the affiliate partner. Same budget, about 400 more customers who stay over a year.
  2. 2Tie the paid social agency's $3K monthly fee to customers found in billing. Paying on 420 instead of the 720 they report saves about $15K a year.
  3. 3Review the creator program after 60 days, once codes are in place.

Questions answered in your readout

Your script for the next agency review

  1. 1.“How many of the customers you're reporting can we find in our billing?”
  2. 2.“How many of them were still subscribed after 90 days?”
  3. 3.“What would you change if we paid you on those numbers?”

Ready before the holidays if you start by Dec 8.

Built by a fractional CMO who runs this on his own agency partners.

Book a call